The Virtual Birder
The Virtual Birder ®
The Store
OnLocation
B-Mail
Real Birds
Hot Links
Gallery
Media Shelf
Prizes
EdCentral
Rants & Raves
Media Shelf

Product Review:
Music of the Birds:
Celebration of Bird Song

by Lang Elliott

Review by Fred Bouchard


Buy Now!

Music of the Birds:
Celebration of Bird Song

by Lang Elliott
Houghton Mifflin
October 1999
136 pages, Paperback
9.53 x 9.03 x 0.50 inches
1 Audio CD, 74 Minutes
Over 125 Color Photos
Over 70 species
ISBN: 0-618-00697-4

Scan of Chapter 3: Lesser Musicians, pp. 56-57 (194K)

As a music reviewer and radio programmer, the aesthetics of recorded music are foremost in my thoughts. "What sounds beautiful?" "Who plays the more imaginative versions of Autumn Leaves?" "Why do I like Scherchen's low-fi, scratchy version of Mozart's Requiem better than Abbado's brilliant, high-tech one?"

This sense of aesthetic discrimination influences my birding habits. Just as I derive more visual joy from from watching blue jays hop around in my backyard oak than I do scoping dowitchers at 300 yards, l prefer to hear the pristine piccolo of our everyday White-throated Sparrow to the more elusive buzzsaw of a Cerulean Warbler.

As listening to birds is an increasingly precious ability as my auditory acumen dims in middle age, it is with pleasure that I read Lane Elliott's examination and celebration of bird song. This unique book gives voice to the poetic and aesthetic aspects of mans' perception of bird song. Elliott -- a writer, recordist, and photographer best known for his work in Stokes Field Guide to Bird Songs: Eastern Region -- affords us his seasoned choice of the finest avian singers of North America. He follows his aural agenda in every aspect of this book. Nearly every bird mentioned in his flowing text is accompanied by a color portrait, shown in full voice, beak open and sometimes nearly exploding with air (and rapture).

Elliott turns ontological order topsy turvy and leads with the virtuosi of the bird world: the thrushes. The other leading songsters Elliott selects are wrens, singing sparrows, finches, mimics, and meadowlarks. Bobolink, American Robin, Red-breasted Grosbeak, tanagers, Northern Cardinal, and Baltimore Oriole also make the Top Twenty.

The CD follows the book's order and the author actually reads bits of his text, weaving quotes into his remarks prefacing the songs. There are some nice surprises. Elliott slows thrush songs to 1/3 speed so we may revel in the Veery's waterfall, the Hermit Thrush's wooden flute, and the Swainson Thrush's rich overtones. These renderings, ever surprising and haunting in their unearthy beauty, may alone merit the cover price.

Of the 50 other tracks on the disc, lesser songsters include buzzy sparrows (the Henslow's song is slowed to show niceties) and several backyard familiars (phoebe, titmouse, nuthatch, chickadee, crow).

Elliott cherry-picks a few flight, dawn and night songs, and male/female duets (Red-wing Blackbird, Cowbird). Warblers making the cut include Ovenbird and Common Yellowthroat (typical and flight song); Northern Parula, Blue-winged, and Black-throated Green Warblers (typical and dawn song). Mimic repertoire of the Chat (along with Mockingbird and Starling) are compared with species imitated. House Finch's courtship song and Purple Finch's aerial predator song are also perceptive inclusions.

The many poetic inclusions, from perceptive, humorous to the rapturous babblings over the indescribably bubbly Bobolink, remind me of those that once graced the Brookline Bird Club's bluebooks (our local bird club's bulletin). Among Elliott's more memorable quotations are Trowbridge's apt and aspirate articulations upon hearing the dowager denizen of dells:

Like liquid pearls fresh showered from heaven,

The high notes of the lone wood-thrush

Fall on the forest's holy hush.

and Clarence Hawkes amused musing on a parley of unmusical grackles:

The morning is ringing--not with their singing,

But with their talking, they're piping and squawking

Some scandalous ditty, the more then's the pity.

Particularly fascinating is Elliott's recounting of the writers' emotive expressions which transcend their metier. Some of the scientific observations appear charmingly romantic, and a few celebrations in poesy are laser-sharp. H. W. Longfellow's description of the Wood Thrush's call as a "silver bell" seems exceptionally precise, while Frank Chapman's "Aeolian harp" seems rather whimsical.

Many quotations, far from being specific, merely express the awestruck wonderment of man, God's child in the woods. Here, too, Elliott's selections shine. Henry Thoreau's marvellous comment strikes us as a deja-vu revelation: "We find that we had virtually forgotten the note of each bird, and when we hear it again it is remembered like a dream, reminding us of a previous state of existence." And we identify readily with Elizabeth Browning's shedding day-to-day petty woes a-field:

The little cares that fretted me

I lost them yesterday...

Among the singing of the birds

The humming of the bees.

Elliott's handsomely recorded songs of avian divas, his vivid portraits, and his thoughtful selections from two centuries of naturalists, scholars, and poets all serve to give us pause in our well-intentioned work of trudging, listing, emailing, and censusing. We may not need yet another spin on the field guide, but we can certainly use a happy reminder that our true pursuit is simply that of beauty.


Fred Bouchard writes about music, food and wine, and travel for many national and international publications. Fred lives in Brookline, Massachusetts.

Fred can be reached at fbouchard@juno.com.

[ Back to Top ]


[ The Virtual Birder Home Page]

Send feedback on these pages to: MediaShelf@greatblue.com
Copyright © 1997-1999 Great Blue Media Works. All rights reserved.
Last Updated: Friday, December 24, 1999 12:58pm EST